BALANCING STATE POWER AND PERSONAL LIBERTY

This article is written by Lalit Wangi. Which analyzes the warrantless arrest under the Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.

  1. Introduction:

The word “arrest” originated in the 14th century from the old French word “arester” and the Vulgar Latin word “arrestare,” meaning “to stop or stay.” According to Kelkar, arrest is “the compulsory restraint of a person in order to bring him within the control of the law and subject him to the process of criminal justice.”

In State of Haryana v. Dinesh Kumar, the Supreme Court held that in a legal sense, arrest consists of taking into custody another person under authority empowered by law.

The primary objective of taking any person into custody of law is to bring the accused before the court of law to face the proceeding of the court.

  1. Types of arrest:

The term “arrest” has not been defined anywhere under BNSS 2023. But it classified the arrest into two broad categories:

  • Arrest with Warrant (Section 35 BNSS): The arrest done by a legal officer or any other person under the authority of a magistrate in the form of a warrant is referred to as an arrest with warrant.
  • Arrest without Warrant: The primary provisions under BNSS that deal with arrest without a warrant are Section 35(1), Section 39, Section 40, Section 41, Section 170, and Section 473.
  • Who can be arrested:
  • Police Officer: A police officer can arrest a person under sections 35 and 39 of BNSS.
    • Section 35: When can police arrest without a warrant? —
    • Section 39: Arrest by Police on refusal to give name and residence.
  • Magistrate: A magistrate, whether judicial or executive, is empowered to arrest any other person within its jurisdiction under section 41 of BNSS. (Arrest by Magistrate)
  • Private Person: a person who in his presence commits a non-bailable and cognizable offense and any proclaimed offender.
  • Cases in which a police can arrest without a warrant
    • When police can arrest without warrant:Section 2(g): the section 2(g) of sanhita state that the police officer can arrest any person without a warrant if the offence committed is cognizable in nature.Section 35(1): Arrest without warrant: provides that a police officer can a arrest any other person without the authority of magistrate under the any of the following circumstances lay down and the clause (a) to (j).Committed cognizable offence: the police officer can arrest any person who has committed the cognizable offence in his presence.
    • Offence punishable with 7 years or less imprisonment: upon the satisfaction of the following condition can arrest any person against whom a-
  • Reasonable complaint has been made
  • Credible information has been received
  • A reasonable suspicion exist

The conditions which must be satisfied by the police officer for the arrest of a person without warrant for the offence punishable with 7 years less are as follows:

  • Reason to believe.
    • Satisfied that: the police officer is satisfied that the arrest is necessary:
    • a. To prevent such person from committing any further offence
      • For the purpose of better investigation of offence, or
      • To prevent such person from causing the tempering with evidences in any manner
      • To prevent such persons from inducing, threatening, coercing, or promising any person acquainted with the fact of the cases to hinder in the process of justice.
      •  Unless such person is arrested his presence cannot be insured in the court.

The parameters given under this section where inserted in CrPC by 2009 amendment in furtherance of guidelines lay down in Joginder Kumar v State of UP.

  • Offence punish people with life imprisonment, death, etc.
    • Proclaimed offender.
    • Possessor of stolen property.
    • Obstruct police officer
    • Deserter.
    • Offence outside India
    • Breach of section 394(5
    • Requisition.
  • Arrest in Non-cognizable offence: the police officer under section 39 of BNSS is empowered to a rest any person even in non cognizable cases, if such person-
    • Refuses to disclose his name and address.
    • officer has a reason to believe the disclose Name and address is not valid 

Then search person can be detained until the information is ascertained.

  • Preventive arrest (Section 170): if the officer is satisfying that such person it going to commit a cognizable offence and the arrest is necessary for prevention of such offense.
  • Breach of Condition under section 473: any person whose sentence has been suspended or emitted by the state government upon the certain condition and he has breach that condition.
    • Arrest by Private Person without Warranty

The circumstances in which a private person can arrest are:

  1. A person has committed a non-bailable and cognizable offence in his presence, or
    1. Such person is a proclaimed offender.

5.3 Procedure after arrest:

without necessary delay, but within 6 hour from arrest, such private person shall make over or cause to be made over that person so arrested to a police officer or in the absence of police officer takes such arrested person to the nearest police station.

  • Arrest by Magistrate

Section 41 of BNSS provides that the magistrate whether executive or judicial as a power to make a rest under the following circumstances.

  • The offence must be committed in the presence of magistrate
  • Such offense must be committed within his local jurisdiction
  • Statutory safeguard available to Accused against arrest

6.1 Appearance Notice under Section 35:

No person who is accused of commission of an offence punishable with imprisonment of less 7 years be arrested by a police officer except under a warrant or order of magistrate. Rather than making immediate arrest the police officer must issue were notice of appearance to the accused.

6.2 Procedural complaints of section 36:

Every police officer while making an arrest cell comply with the provisional safeguard lay down on the section 36 of BNSS, guidelines lay down under D.K Vasu Case to its development under Satendra Kumar Antil v. CBI.

  • accurate, visible and clear identification of his name.
  • Prepare a memorandum, attested by at least one witness who is the member of family of the person arrested.
  • Inform the person arrested.

6.3 Mandatory written ground of arrest

Section 47(1) of BNSS along with Article 22(1) of Constitution, In Vihan Kumar v. State of Haryana The honourable supreme court held

at the arrested person has a fundamental right to know the grounds of his arrest upon

the failure of compliance with it, the arrest shall become invalid an accuse must immediately release.

6.4 Production before magistrate:

Section 50 of BNSS outlines the objective enshrined under Article 22(2) of Constitution, In Hanumant Jagannath v. State of Maharashtra

 The honourable court held that the only time excluded from the period of 24 hours is duration of travel between place of arrest to court of magistrate. Its cell not include prearrest medical test.

6.5 Protection first senior citizen and infirm person:

Section 35 also provide that the inform and the senior citizen are protected from arrest. Instead of being arrested they shall be release on Bond or bail Bond as furnished another procedure lay down under the Sanhita.

6.6 Right to legal representation:

 Article 22(1)of Constitution and Section 38 of BNSS. Honourable supreme court in Mohammed Ajmal Amir Kasab v. State of Maharashtra held at it is a duty of magistrate and

court to inform the indigen accused about his right to get free legal aid.

6.7 Protection from self incrimination: Article 20 (2) of Constitution along with section 23of BSA

lay downs that no person accused of any often shall be compel to be a witness against himself. It was your firm by the honourable supreme court in the landmark ruling of state of Bombay v. Kathi kallu. 

6.8 Right to Bail

Section 47(2) of BNSS state when a police officer arrests a person without a Warrant

is entitle to be release on bill and he may arrange for sureties on his behalf.

6.9 Medical examination:

Section 53 of BNSS compel person to undergone a medical examination with a view to facilitate investigation;

it also gives the right to accuse person to have him medical examine.

  • Suggestion and reforms in present system 

7.1.Judical scrutiny:

Instead of mechanical or non-speaking remand orders. Upon violation of lay down provision the officer strictly punished instead of giving a warning.

7.2 Digital entry:

the legislature and judiciary should lay down the guideline and develop a software for,

digital entry of any action taken by them.

7.3 Legal aid at station:

Instead of running from police station to court and court to station,

the government should create a collaboration between the police station and bar.

7.4 Monitoring body:

 the government should constitute a monitoring body to observe the action of police office

whether the complaint with the provision and safeguard lay down under the code and constitution. And forward report at regular interval district magistrate to review the conduct.

  • Conclusion

The authority to arrest is the fundamental power of the police officers. The police officer can arrest a person either through warrant or without warrant under special circumstances lay down in BNSS. But such power is not absolute. Aligning with the principal of “Absolute power corrupts absolutely” the code and constitution lay down certain

safeguard to protect such accused from being arrested or upon arrest, confer rights to protect its interest.